Organiser
Get it on Google Play
Get it on Google Play

Opinion

Inspect Accountability of International NGOs

Pankaj Jayaswal

Pankaj JayaswalSep 17, 2021, 02:21 PM IST

Inspect Accountability of International NGOs

IB (Intelligence Bureau) raised serious doubts about foreign funding and its relation to PIL or public protest by these NGOs to stall government projects or close private industry.

 

India has more than 3.1 million non-governmental organisations (NGOs); the number is much bigger than the number of schools, hospitals, and police personnel. There are around 22400 NGOs in India registered under the foreign contribution regulation act (FCRA).

In a statement by a minister in Rajya Sabha this year states that NGOs working in India and registered under FCRA have received 50,975 crores from abroad in the last four years. The highest donation was received from the USA to the tune of 19941 crores.

Union Minister of State for Home Nityanand Rai said 18,304 NGOs received 15,355 crores in 2016-17; 18,235 NGOs received 16,940 crores in 2017-18; 16,490 crores by 17,540 NGOs in 2018-19 and 2,190 crores by 3,475 NGOs in 2019-20.

The government of India has banned 20,600 NGOs in the last 11 years, which received huge donations under FCRA but didn't file annual returns as informed by Nityanand Rai in Lok Sabha in Feb 2021. There are serious doubts about the functioning of many NGOs in India. First, IB (Intelligence Bureau) raised serious doubts about foreign funding and its relation to PIL or public protest by these NGOs to stall government projects or close private industry.

Even Delhi HC raised doubts in March 2013 by saying, "Most private run so called philanthropic organisations do not understand their social responsibilities. 99% of the existing NGOs are fraud and simply moneymaking devices. Only one out of every hundred NGOs serve the purpose they are set up for," a bench headed by Justice Pradeep Nandrajog said.

It's good to have concerns and commitment to work for environment protection, women empowerment, village development. However, if it is creating obstacles for the developmental activities with no concrete evidence about environmental degradation or loss to local people and having no solution which will benefit people and government, socially and economically, then intention really matters, and obvious doubts arise about the functioning of NGO.

Sterlite Tuticorin plant has been closed after a lot of agitation by a few NGOs. Has the production of copper stopped worldwide? Many agitations and PIL (Public Interest Litigation) filings happened earlier, which delayed or stopped projects or closed down factories, damaging the integrity of the government and country in the eyes of investors resulting in huge losses to our country and delay in the development, affecting GDP and overall economic performance leading to a rise in unemployment, poor standard of living, social unrest. The intention should be to find out the solution that is environmentally and human friendly; closing down is not the right solution in the first instance. We respect the court's verdict. However, the case needs to be presented in the right manner by NGOs before the court, so our courts can suggest the right solution.

What we as Indians expect from NGOs working for environment protection, village development and women empowerment.

  •  India is seriously working for the betterment of the environment. Solar power is one such story, over 100 GW installed and working with a bigger target and going ahead with the Paris agreement. We expect NGOs to help government agencies to spread and make it possible to install maximum capacity in towns and villages with the huge foreign funding they receive. Market the Indian companies across the globe working for solar power so that carbon footprints can be minimised. It will be helpful for environmental betterment if these international NGOs work to encourage solar power and other renewable sources of energy in countries like China and America, which produce the highest carbon footprints.
  • Since huge funds are collected for poor and village development, can they help in this issue? The majority of women in villages are used for cooking food using chulha (burning of wood), causing deforestation and smoke coming out of chulha is very harmful, triggering chronic diseases. The central government has provided more than eight crore LPG cylinders to these women to minimise deforestation and for the better health of women. Can NGO's help in refilling the cylinders regularly and provide free LPG cylinders to the people still in need? Can they appeal to the governments of other countries to follow the footprints of the Indian government?
  •  Indian government built crores of toilets to stop open defecation. It has resulted in a lesser amount of diseases resulting in saving money for the poor. What role did NGOs play with such huge funding?
  • NGOs' intention and working attitude should not be to stall the project or close down the factory. If any environmental concerns are needed to be addressed, they should be addressed with their solutions along with the authorities of the company and government. This will actually help NGOs for their objective to make a positive impact in the lives of people.
  • If the government has banned a few NGOs owing to non-compliance of rules and regulations, non-filing of annual returns, then NGOs, their supportive agencies, and few media houses should not oppose the ban. Government and every person have the right to know how public money has been spent. The question is, why do few NGOs hide it by not filing their annual returns?
  • What are NGOs doing in Afghanistan and Pakistan where women suffering through many unfair practices?
  • NGOs actually need to study the great heritage of this country in relation to Yoga, Pranayam, meditation, Ayurveda, and homoeopathy and spread it worldwide for the betterment of the planet.
  • NGOs should work and fund rivers cleaning and water management programmes. 

The funds raised for a good social purpose should not be diverted for any other stake or should not be used for personal motives. Transparency in functioning and accounting should be on top priority. I am not saying all NGOs are bad. However, those who have bad intentions government will deal with them according to legal and fair practices.

The amendments made by the central government in FCRA to monitor funding and curb illegal practices are;

As per the amended law, providing Aadhaar numbers of the office bearers of the NGOs has been made mandatory for registration of NGOs under the FCRA. Besides, with the amendments, office expenses were brought down to 20 per cent from 50 per cent, and electoral contenders, government servants, members of any legislature and political parties were prohibited from accepting foreign funding.

According to the rules issued after amending the FCRA, NGOs, which intend to receive foreign funding, must have the presence of at least three years and spent a sum of 15 lakhs in voluntary activities prior to their applications.
The NGOs will also have to submit a specific commitment letter from the donor indicating the amount of foreign contribution, and the purpose for which it is proposed is to be given.

The accountability of NGOs needs to be fixed in accordance with social and government norms to avoid any added motive or agenda, which harms the interest of society and the country. The gullible westerners and Indians need to be vigilant about donations they are offering to any NGO. First, you should know in depth the details about the functioning of the NGO and then only move ahead with the necessary help.

Comments
user profile image
Anonymous
on Sep 18 2021 11:26:02

True

Also read: The wilful misuse of socio-environmental issues to undermine the Hindu faith ..

Kanailal Dutt: Hero Of First Revolution

Download Organiser Mobile App:
Mobile App: https://play.google.com/store/apps/de...

Visit Us At:
Website: https://www.organiser.org/

Follow us on:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/eOrganiser

Koo: https://www.kooapp.com/profile/eOrganiser

Twitter: https://twitter.com/eOrganiser

Telegram: https://t.me/eorganiser

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/organiser_weekly

Background Music Credits: https://www.bensound.com

Also read: Factsheet: Jihadi violence against Hindu minorities in Bangladesh ..

State Govt Order Permitting Only A Muslim Priest To Perform Rituals At Datta Peeta Violates Right To Religion Of Both Hindus And Muslims: Karnataka HC
Spiritual Nationalism: Why Indian Nationalism is Universal in Nature?

Israeli rights model emulative

Throughout the history of world civilizations, the welfare of the entire humanity, particularly the defenseless and downtrodden,  has been one of the central concerns of conscientious social thinkers . In modern times, philosophers, political scientists and statesmen have defined the state as a positive entity created to foster the multi-faceted development of all its living beings. Regrettably, however, most of the states in the Middle East and Africa care little for their citizens in our ...

Israeli rights model emulative

Most popular