Current Issue
Organiser Home
The Moving Finger Writes
Media Watch
Thinking Aloud
Kids Org.
News Round-up
Readers’ Forum:
Kerala Newsletter

Previous Issues
September 04, 2011

August 28, 2011
August 21, 2011
August 14, 2011
August 07, 2011

July 31, 2011
July 24, 2011
July 17, 2011
July 10, 2011
July 03, 2011

June 26, 2011
June 19, 2011
June 12, 2011
June 05, 2011

May 29, 2011
May 22, 2011
May 15, 2011
May 08, 2011
May 01, 2011

April 24, 2011
April 17, 2011
April 10, 2011
April 03, 2011

March 27, 2011
March 20, 2011
March 13, 2011
March 06, 2011

February 27, 2011
February 20, 2011
February 13, 2011
February 06, 2011

January 30, 2011
January 23, 2011
January 16, 2011
January 09, 2011
January 02, 2011

December 26, 2010
December 19, 2010
December 12, 2010
December 05, 2010
November 28, 2010
November 21, 2010
November 14, 2010
November 7, 2010

October 31, 2010
October 24, 2010
October 17, 2010
October 10, 2010
October 03, 2010

2010 Issues
2009 Issues
2008 Issues
2007 Issues
2006 Issues

About us
Contact us


March 27, 2011

Page: 35/36

Home > 2011 Issues > March 27, 2011

Another victory for Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti
Court directs ICSE to remove from textbooks all defamatory references on national heroes

By Pramod Kumar

Additional District Session Judge of Delhi, Shri Inder Jeet Singh, directed the Indian Certificate of Secondary Education Board (ICSE Board) to remove all defamatory references regarding freedom fighters in its history and civic books from the next academic session. The order came on March 3 following a suit filed by Advocate Monika Arora on behalf of Shri Dina Nath Batra of the Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti, Shri Ved Prakash Kumar, Dr KV Paliwal, Shri Ramgopal Aggarwal and Shri Gauri Shankar Bhardwaj seeking deletion of defamatory passages in the Std-X History and Civics, Part-II book. The ICSE Board has 118 schools in Maharashtra alone. While Mumbai and Delhi have 60 and the National Capital Region has 30 schools. Over one lakh students from Maharashtra alone opt for ICSE Board examination every year.

This directive of the court is a major victory for Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti which has been fighting at all fronts for the removal of the defamatory references from the textbooks prepared by the government-controlled educational boards and institutions like NCERT, ICSE Board, etc.

Talking to Organiser in New Delhi one of the petitioners Shri Dina Nath Batra expressed satisfaction over the court's directive. He said the Delhi High Court had clearly directed the NCERT and the Union HRD Ministry some time back to ensure deletion of all defamatory passages from the textbooks being taught to students in schools. In spite of that the teaching of objectionable passages continued in the ICSE schools. "The hon’ble judge Shri Inder Jeet Singh has rightly commented that if Bhagat Singh was alive he definitely would not have liked the remarks being taught about him in the textbooks today. During the course of proceedings he directed the ICSE Board to send circular to all its schools through registered post and present the evidence of dispatching the circular in the court," Shri Batra said. He pointed out that the Union HRD Ministry also, on June 9, 2008, had written to the NCERT to replace all the books containing objectionable passages with the new books which contain no objectionable passages. But even after that instruction the teaching of the defamatory passages continued in the ICSE textbooks. "It appears there is a well-planned conspiracy to defame the freedom fighters. But the Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti will not tolerate it in any form," he added.

The book in question was published by Goyal Brothers Prakashan and was written by DN Kundra. It had a chapter, "Radical Nationalism and Rise of Extremism", in which Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Lala Lajpat Rai, Bipin Chandra Pal had been referred to as "militants and extremists", while Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev were described as "terrorists". Now under its direction the Court directed the ICSE Board to call these leaders as ‘nationalists’ and ‘revolutionaries’. The Court also restrained the ICSE Board from publishing the book with the wrong information.

This case was filed in October 2010 seeking directions to the Union of India, ICSE Board and Council for Indian School Certificate Examination to develop a mechanism at both Central and State levels so that the textbooks are scrutinised by a special committee of experts comprising of all the stakeholders in education before publication. "We are deeply aggrieved by the defamatory, derogatory, insulting and objectionable language used to refer to the freedom fighters who laid down their lives for getting freedom for our country and the people. It is very unfortunate that despite getting freedom in 1947, such objectionable and insulting portions regarding our historical past have not been removed from the course material and the young minds are continuously being taught that the people who fought for the freedom of the country were terrorists, extremists, militants who led to Indian unrest," the petition said.

"It is highly shameful that even after more than 64 years of Independence we continue to teach our children defamatory words about our freedom fighters and great personalities. It appears a well-planned campaign on the part of the left historians to insult and degrade the great personalities of this country. It is time we should stand up against all this nonsense and oppose them wherever we find it," said Smt Monika Arora, the counsel for the petitioners, while talking to Organiser.

During the course of judicial proceedings itself, the writer (DN Kundra) and publisher (Goyal Publisher) deleted relevant passage/words/phrases/titles, etc. (i.e. "Militant, Radical, Rationalism or Extremism, Extremist, Militant Nationalism, out of desperation, they took to terrorism, terrorists remained more active, extremist party, impact of revolutionary terrorism on national movement, or the like expressions"), by introducing words like "Revolutionary or Nationalist or Revolutionary Nationalism", in consonance to remove allegations of the plaint. The Council for Indian School Certificate Examination also issued circular to its affiliated schools, so that the concerned schools and teachers teach the students the revised syllabus material.

The Council for Indian School Certificate Examination also issued a circular followed by corrigendum that in the syllabus to be taught in the affiliated schools, will not contain words Extremist, Militants, Radicals, etc and action will also be taken for future curriculum to be issued from time to time. The court expressed satisfaction over the revision of the textbook. However, it further restrained the writer and the publisher from publishing and printing any text, under the title History & Civics Part II, by using the objectionable expressions.

At the same time the court also directed the Union of India and the Council for Indian School Certificate Examination to issue appropriate instructions/guidelines, either in their regular standing instructions/curriculum/syllabus, that such objectionable passage are not to be taught or published in any form by the concerned or affiliated schools.

Previous Page Previous Page (34/36) - Next Page (36/36) Next Page

copyright© 2004 Bharat Prakashan(Delhi) Ltd. All Rights Reserved
Designed and Hosted by KSHEERAJA Web Solutions Pvt Ltd