It’s not CBI Vs CBI! It is the Bureaucracy which is in War from Within and with Each other
Neither CBI Vs CBI, nor Alok Verma Vs Rakesh Asthana, the issue is about the infliction of the public institutions
by the Congress culture. Time to re-boot them!
The rot in the CBI and other similar agencies has taken long in making. The race for supremacy, negative competition and accusing motives constitute the DNA of the Congress culture which was thriving
Long overdue was the inevitable the crash or collapse of the CBI – notorious police organisation - derisively known by choicest epithets (Congress Bureau of Investigation; Corruption Bureau of Intelligence; Caged Parrot of Investigation).
Credibility and integrity of the CBI at stake due to war between its Director and Special Directors? Also, the newly appointed Director facing tainted record as reported in the media.
And, the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) jumped into the fray to resolve the crisis in the CBI. Not to be left behind, even the Intelligence Bureau (IB) got struck into quagmire of controversy with its sleuths apprehended by the CBI security personnel guarding the Directors residence.
Furthermore, the Enforcement Directorate and the Income Tax authorities are conducting raids all over the nation against suspected defaulters.
Of course, all opposition parties are crying foul - “Political Vendetta” - as if all of them are “holier than their rivals” and leaders of highest standards of virtue. PILs in the Courts are piling up as if the judiciary is above board.
From the Past
Ipso facto, since the days of Indira Gandhi, credibility and integrity of not only the CBI but also the judiciary was tarnished. Yet, none made an attempt to clean the dirty stables. Pliable officers were always available at the beck and call of their political masters.
Throughout history, be it in monarchy or democracy, rulers used criminal and corrupt guiles to grab and retain power. Lord Acton stated: “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely…Great (political) men are almost always bad men. …If the people knew what sorts of men statesmen were they would rise and hang the whole lot of them”.
Today, almost all institutions of the state are in disarray due to conflicts from within abetted by their political patrons. Recently, we saw the judges going public to the media highlighting the murky happenings in the Supreme Court. Now, former Justice Chalameshwar as per media reports is all set to join the bandwagon of political party in his home state.
Even the judiciary that enjoys the autonomy of “collegiums” for recommending names for appointment of judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts cannot absolve themselves of accountability for appointed tainted personalities exposed in corruption whilst in service.
Naïve it is to expect the CBI – all political appointees - to fearlessly uphold institutional credibility and integrity.
Responsibility of the Political Class
Ipso facto, political leadership is squarely responsible for all the mechanisms of anti-corruption subverted: JPCs, CVC, CBI, CAG, ED, Courts of Law and so on. Had they been performing their duties without political interference, the rapid spread of tentacles of corruption strangulating the society could have been avoided. Such is the ingenious capacity of the few vested political and bureaucratic interests and their strangulating grip.
To whom should the responsibility and accountability for rapid spread of corruption be assigned over the past 71 years in all fields and at all levels? Congress Party and corruption are synonymous was a common refrain in the past: 'Kalpatharuvu or Mahavruksham’ of corruption.
Surely, the Congress Party, having governed the State for over 60 years out of 71 years cannot now shed crocodile tears or champion the exposure of murky happenings resulting in the “Crash or Collapse of the CBI, CVC, IB, ED, IT and others”.
Double standards are flourishing everywhere. No room for ethics, morals and values. They have no other objective except corruption. The permanent deepest desire is the desire for security or self preservation - a necessary selfish, aggressive and acquisitive desire in a world where all cannot survive.
Expert analysts have predicted India as a rising economic super power following China closely. It is but natural for the existing crop of entrenched dynamic individuals to manipulate the system to their advantage in pursuit of wealth, social status and power. When the system permits or encourages corruption, why will the few entrenched in the system desist from exploiting it to their advantage. In particular, when there are other new entrants waiting to exploit such opportunities to their advantage.
Scandals after Scandals
Let me broadly recount corruption scandals and scams includes: 1949 - Industry minister Rao Shiv Bahadur Singh, father of Arjun Singh, for taking a bribe of Rs 25,000 from gemstone trader Sachendubhai Baron for renewing his diamond mining lease; 1951 - Mudgal scandal; 1955 - Jeep Scandal V K Krishna Menon; 1957 - Haridas Mundhra Insurance company scandal; 1959 – Dalmia Bharat Insurance Company misappropriation scandal; 1960 – Dharma Teja Rs.22 crores loan scandal; 1954 - Pratap Singh Kairon resignation; 1965 – Biju Patnaik favors to his own Kalinga Tubes Company: 1971 – Rs.60 lakhs Nagarwala scam; 1974 – Maruti scandal; 1976 - US $ 200 Mn Kuo Oil deal scam linked to Indira Gandhi and Sanjay Gandhi; and so on.
Of course heading the scams during the UPA rule of 10 years includes: Common Wealth Games; Augusta Westland Helicopter Deal; 2G spectrum; Coal Mining Blocks allotment; Adarsh Housing; Aircel Maxis; Reliance Gas scam; Radia Tapes Controversy; Hasan Ali Khan US$ 11.11 Billion scam; Housing loans; Belekeri port; Lavasa Scandal; UP Food Grain Scam; AP Industrial Infrastructure Corporation Controversy; ISRO-Devas S band Scam; IPL Cricket Scandals; Madhu Koda mining scam; Satyam scandal; Cash For Votes Scandal and others.
Add to them, names to include: Rs. 4,000 crores Harshad Mehta securities scam; Palmolein Oil Import Scam; Railway Engines; House allotments; Gold Star/ABFL; Thal Vaishet project to a subsidiary of Italian Snamprogetti; Antulay Trust scandal; HDW Submarine Purchase Kickback – US$ 100 million; Cement Scam involving A R Antulay; Enron scandal; 1986 Bofors; 1989 St. Kitts Forgery; Air Bus A 320 deal; Telephone equipment’s & STC purchases; 1991 Jain Hawala case; Scorpene Deal Scam; Oil-for-food programme (Natwar Singh); Cash for Querry; MPLAD scam; Gegong Apang PDS Scam; Telgi Stamp Paper Scam; Taj corridor scandal; Home Trade Scam; UTI Scam; Ketan Parekh securities; Barak Missile Scandal; Calcutta Stock Exchange; Tehelka Sting; Kargil Coffingate; UTI Mutual Fund scam; The Telecom Scam; SNC Lavalin scandal; Bihar fodder scam; Oil and gas distributorship; Indian Bank loans; Lakhubhai Pathak Paper Pulp Contract Bribery; JM Bribery; Fertiliser Import Scam; Sukh Ram Telecom Equipment Scandal; Purulia arms drop and so on.
The list of VIPs allegedly involved is impressive. Indira Gandhi, Rajiv Gandhi, PV Narasimha Rao, Jaffer Sharief, Arun Nehru, Sheila Kaul, Shankaranand, Rameshwar Thakur, Kalpanath Rai, Ram Lakhan Singh Yadav, PV Prabhakar Rao, Harshad Mehta, JMM leaders, Shuk Ram, Satish Sharma, Laloo Prasad Yadav, Ramalinga Raju etc. The latest to join the illustrious list are Sonia and Rahul Ghandy and Robert Vadra, Ashok Chavan, Suresh Kalmadi, A Raja, Kanimozhi, Lalit Modi, Vijaya Mallya, Nirav Modi, Mehul Choksi, Alok Verma, Rakesh Asthana etc.
The story of ‘Dhirubhai Ambani’ empire building was based on exploiting the opportunities of ‘License Raj” regime. If Mukesh and Anil Ambani are continuing with their fathers inherited legacy, none should be surprised about it. After all, the system perpetuates it. Many more ‘Ambanis” are in the making what with India poised to emerge as an economic super power.
In retrospect, India is rapidly emerging as the corruption superpower. The clichés that “all are equal before Law”, “Justice delayed is justice denied” and “Law to take its own course” are democratic frauds committed on society to perpetuate corruption in eternity. If the corrupt roam around unashamedly free, collapse modern India will be sooner than later unable to narrow the gap between the rich and the poor.
The “Crash or Collapse of the CBI” and the clash between the CVC, CBI and IB provides both a challenge and opportunity to cleanse the system provided the complete overhaul of the ‘system’ is effectively formulated and implemented without “fear or favor”.